Ok Baseball World, Armando Gallaraga of the Detroit Tigers is holding an online chat today. A great deal of controversy has arisen over his imperfect perfect game that occurred two weeks ago. (Login or read the transcript on the Detroit Tigers chat site)
When it happened everyone in the game was in uproar over Gallaraga’s would be perfect game that was snatched forever away from the record books by a botched call with two outs in the 9th that would have been the final out in the would be 3rd Perfect Game of the 2010 season.
It’s an incredible mistake that is being examined, picked, plucked, scrutinized and could possibly change the future of the game forever.
And the man who made the history making decision? …..an Umpire (who by the way was voted the best MLB umpire in a poll conducted by ESPN.)
Here are some of my thoughts on the situation. I’ve long thought about sharing my thoughts about my life’s experience as the wife of a professional umpire, because few think about the perspective of umpires and their importance in the game. This situation seemed like the perfect source of inspiration. Call me partial, but out of all sports, I think umpires should be the most respected out of all sports officials. They undergo such tremendous pressure, night after night with few breaks, extreme daily mental and physical stress, and the expectation of daily perfection.
A tremendous celebration occurs with each Perfect Game, Grand Slam, 10-game hit streak, Walk-off Homer, etc, etc. BUT- no one celebrates an umpire for a perfectly called game or each game where every whacker play is called with perfect accuracy….It’s a funny reality in the sport we love so much where fans love to hate the very men who dedicate their lives to maintain the integrity of the game by calling each play as they see it with absolute certainty. Fans don’t realize that umpires determine themselves to call each game, each play, as fairly and accurately as possible.
Players can go for weeks without a single hit or can make three fielding errors in a single game, or can blow what would be the biggest save of a playoff series….we as fans can so easily forgive and forget. But for an umpire grace is not so easily bestowed even though it should be as their intentions remain true to the game.
Does anyone really think that the final out of a would-be perfect game would have been called safe if the ump had not truly believed that the runner had beat the play? C’mon, people let’s be serious. Imperfection happens. And it’s these oh so human moments that make our great game so special as they remind us that life will never be perfect, life has it’s glorious triumphs, it’s heartbreaking disappointments…baseball like life is wrought with reality – both sides of it.
Let’s not change that truth.
See the game story here.